• Home  / 
  • Lifestyle
  •  /  The Best Waterproof Mascara – 2017 Reviews and Comparison

The Best Waterproof Mascara – 2017 Reviews and Comparison

The Best Waterproof Mascara Reviews

The Best Waterproof Mascara Reviews

Rain is technically a woman's enemy—a woman who wears make-up that is. It's true that one of the biggest worries of a woman when wearing make-up is getting wet. Whether it be sweat or rain or other forms of humidity, it does not go well with typical make-up. And t is a major problem because we always want to look our best. We practically spend at least about an hour to make ourselves look presentable to the public only for it to waste away with a small amount of moisture.

It's a major bummer to deal with especially when you are trying to look your best for work or for your husband. It is a no-brainer when it comes to make-up essentials. It is an item that helps make your eyes pop out. Not only that, it helps frame your eyes by adding volume and length and flavor to your eyelashes.

A woman can bring a nation down to its knees with just a bat of an eye and you can definitely achieve that with the perfect waterproof mascara. If the battle against nature is in hand, then getting yourself a waterproof mascara is definitely the way to go. A solid waterproof mascara doesn't fade out. It stays solid and sleek. It doesn't flake out and neither does it make your lashes feel heavy and brittle. We have made a list of the best waterproof mascaras on the market to help lessen the burden of making you go through an endless list of waterproof mascaras online.

Best Waterproof Mascara Comparison


L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara

Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Mascara

Lash Factory 3D Fiber Lash Mascara

Simply Naked Beauty Best 3D Fiber Lash Mascara

Covergirl LashBlast Waterproof Mascara


L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara
Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Mascara
Lash Factory 3D Fiber Lash Mascara
Simply Naked Beauty Best 3D Fiber Lash Mascara
Covergirl LashBlast Volume Waterproof Mascara


0.28 fl. oz.

0.32 fl. oz.

0.3 fl. oz.

0.54 fl. oz

0.44 fl. oz.


Black, Carbon Black, Black Brown

Blackest Black, Very Black, Brownish Black

One type only

Midnight Black, Dark Chocolate Brown

Black, Very Black

Best for

Waterproof Mascara

Lengthening Lashes


Sensitive Eyes

Quick and Easy Use

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara Review

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara

Have you ever thought bout wearing a mascara going to the gym? Well, why not? You'd like to look your best anytime anywhere and especially if you wanna look extra special for a gym mate then trending your fashion in the gym is not a bad idea. Actually, we love pairing up our make-up with our outfit and even our matching workout headbands. But the problem is the sweat. It makes makeup run and really destroys your total look making you look like as if you entered the gym as Beyonce and go out looking like Mike Tyson. Wouldn't you want that now do you? That's why we chose this waterproof mascara because it makes your makeup look natural.

It seems that everything from the L'Oreal Paris Beauty Line is absolute perfection even this mascara. Aside from the fact that it is actually waterproof, it is really easy to take off without having to worry about rubbing our eyes too much. With just soap and water, it comes off quick. You can also use some other oil-based makeup removers out there if your find washing your face quite a tedious task.

Anyway, we love the color. Whichever you choose, the color is solid all throughout the day. It never seems to fade. It keeps on the luster and the dramatic look throughout the entire day despite a hard day's work. What we love is that it has this eyelash separator feature that doesn't clump your eyelashes up. It creates this smooth look that makes your eyelashes look so much more natural. It doesn't clump, it leaves no flakes and it doesn't smudge either.

It's also great for women who have sensitive eyes because the formulation doesn't have any parabens, no strong chemicals that will react with contact lenses, and no fragrances. It is definitely ophthalmologist and allergy tested so that sensitive eyes won't keep running away with tears and red puffy eyes.

There is more reason to love this mascara and that is why we chose this as our top pick for the best waterproof mascara in the market.

Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Mascara Review

Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Mascara

Okay, we love makeup and we love working out. Well, no matter how hard we try to look great in the gym but when our sweat slides down it just totally ruin it especially when the blackest of the black eyeliner and mascara runs off, that's a really horrific sight to see. Anyway, even if you do exercises that don't make you sweat that much like using exercise balls or resistance bands, you'd still need a real waterproof mascara that flatters your eyes by making your lashes look longer.

With just the right consistency that thickens right upon application makes the Maybelline Waterproof Mascara is definitely the best lengthening waterproof mascara Amazon can offer. The consistency is, right of the bat, perfect. It isn;t runny and it isn't too thick either. Upon application, you will notice that it clings to the lashes immediately making a longer looking set of eyelashes.

We love the brush. The brush has two sides making it much easier to create a customized voluminous eyelashes. The inner curve reaches the tips of the eyelashes without damaging the rest of your make-up while the longer bristles fan out to spread over your lashes from roots to tip. It creates this layered look making your lashes look much longer and much more appealing.

The thing is, your eyelashes have different lengths and depths and sizes and not all lengthening waterproof mascaras can do the job of bringing them all out and make them appear long and equal. And that's practically the job of the Maybelline Lash Sensational Waterproof Mascara. it straightens and evens out your lashes to bring out the full blast of your beautiful lashes. And for that reason, this is our second pick for the best waterproof mascaras but our top pick for the best lengthening waterproof mascaras.

Lash Factory 3D Fiber Lash Mascara Review

Lash Factory 3D Fiber Lash Mascara

Even if your waterproof mascara is, you know, waterproof it also needs to be removed. No worries, mascaras have a special formulation that can easily be removed with a decent make-up remover without it being too clingy and too tough on your eyelashes. Anyway, this mascara is great for lengthening. It makes your eyelashes look longer and fuller.

A lot of women really complain about their short thin lashes or the lack thereof. With so many Caucasian women, having light colored hair is great but not around the eyes. The eye looks bold and big and appears like fish eyes popping out. With the perfect waterproof mascara for volume, you'll never complain about your eyelashes every again. We love just how well the Lash Factory created this formula to create a depth in eyelashes. It really reveals a more dramatic look and even aids in helping the colors of your eyes shine.

We love that it is so easy to use even. It is very safe too. The brush is made with green tea fibers that make it very hypoallergenic to sensitive eyes. It is also great for people who wear contact lenses too. Anyway, it is very great in the application process. It is neat and it isn't messy. It's horrible when you wear a messy waterproof mascara that dries off quickly. It messes up your entire make-up. This one, in particular, is very sleek. You can apply it repetitively to create a beautiful voluminous eyelash that is so desired by most women.

One other great aspect about this is that it doesn't clump up that much. It is pretty light too. Although it flakes a little bit by the end of the day, it doesn't flake that much that it will irritate your eyes. It just breaks off or cracks a little bit and that's as far as it goes by the end of a 16 hour period. And for that, we have chosen this as our third pick for the waterproof mascara and the top pick for the best waterproof mascara for volume.

Simply Naked Beauty Best 3D Fiber Lash Mascara Review

Simply Naked Beauty Best 3D Fiber Lash Mascara

You love going out for a job every morning but still don't want to risk looking like a hag with messy hair and extremely wind burned face while going out for that routine jog. One for the thins we did notice about wearing a waterproof mascara is that it can help your eyes shield dust off. Some women have sensitive eyes and wearing makeup can irritate them making your eyes look red and puffy. So before hitting the tracks and wearing your fitness tracker, try putting this waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes.

Our eyes are quite delicate and even the slightest disturbance causes it to tear up and turn red. Some women have more sensitive eyes that practically render them almost impossible to wear make-up. But that's coming to a close now as more and more cosmetic lines create more natural beauty products and this waterproof mascara by Simply Naked Beauty is just as close to producing the best natural waterproof mascara. The ingredients are non-toxic and natural. There are no parabens, no added chemicals and no disgusting eye irritants and allergy triggering chemical compounds.

We love that it comes with a complete lash kit. It comes with a gel and the fiber to make that full sexy looking eyes. We really love that it also creates smooth-looking eyelashes. Even though it clumps at some point, it doesn't look like a messy clumped up mascara on lashes. It is very easy to use too. Within 5 minutes, you can create that sexy-looking eyes and dramatic effect with a glance kind of look you were aiming for.

We also love that it comes with the case and an extra brush. It is very handy and very simple to use too. It also aims to make your eyes look more natural rather than someone who is wearing an uneven pair of fake lashes. And that is why this is our fourth pick for the best waterproof mascara.

Covergirl LashBlast Volume Waterproof Mascara Review

Covergirl LashBlast Volume Waterproof Mascara

Clumping eyelashes is not everyone's thing. It doesn't flatter very eye shape. In fact, it even makes other people look like as if their eyeballs are popping out of their head. That's not the direction we want to go whenever we wear make-up. We just want to look trendy and fashionable at all times and that is why this is our pick for the easiest application mascara for a quick trend.

CoverGirl is another cosmetic line that never misses. They came up with a great solution for easy mascara application that is super great in your carry on purse—or bag. We love that it is designed to be carried along. We love that it is made to be used for quick and easy application with barely any mess. You'll only really end up messing your make up if you are that clumsy. But still, it can easily be wiped off with the right makes up remover. Anyway, another aspect of the CoverGirl waterproof mascara that we love so much is that it is great in holding up your curls.

We can get frustrated when our eyelashes with a drop like dead hair when e put mascara on because it is too heavy to hold the newly curled eyelashes out. It's a big problem, honestly, but the CoverGirl Lash Blast Waterproof mascara holds against that. It is light and dries up quickly allowing you to keep your eyelashes curled up.

So, no matter which drugstore waterproof mascaras you get, you will keep going back to the waterproof Lash Blast. And for those reasons, this completes our list of five best waterproof mascaras in the market and this is definitely the best drugstore waterproof mascaras you can ever find.

To Sum it Up...

Choosing the right mascara depends on your needs. But overall waterproof mascara is meant to stay longer and make you look at no matter where you are and what you do. There are a lot of waterproof mascaras out there but with our list of best waterproof mascaras in the market, we are sure that you will be happy with our picks and that we are sure that you won't choose another.

Product Image Credits: Amazon.com

About the author

Kaila Sharlene

Kaila Sharlene is a freelance web designer, web developer and SEO specialist - one of the “Top Rated” web designers on Upwork. Visit her website on kailasharlene.com. Living a digital nomad lifestyle, her family loves to explore the outdoors while doing some freelance jobs in between. Know more about their family adventures on wyattmaktrav.com - named after her son Wyatt Maktrav.

Click here to add a comment

Leave a comment: